Due to not having the final draft of the story, the art director didn't know if the illustration would be a single page or a full spread. In my three initial thumbnails, I did both versions.

The AD chose the idea of the woman playing the instrument and breaking through the dark clouds. The heavy, dark negative space of the clouds would allow plenty of room to knock out the header.

For the final, the AD thought the illustration would look better to flip it. Luckily the piece had no reason it couldn't be. This is a scanned spread from the magazine (so the colors may be a little off), but hopefully it'll catch the reader's eyes.
Thanks Lisa and Robert!
